Same Student Anger, Different Spotlight: Why Did Jantar Mantar Get More Coverage Than Jharkhand?

A major student protest outside the Jharkhand Assembly took a dramatic turn on Tuesday as police began dispersing protesters after they refused to leave the area. What began as a largely peaceful demonstration eventually saw clashes between students and police, allegations of lathi-charge, students being forcibly removed, and stones allegedly being thrown at security personnel. The protesters, many of whom had been demonstrating for several days over demands related to recruitment examinations and alleged irregularities in the functioning of the Jharkhand Public Service Commission (JPSC) and Jharkhand Staff Selection Commission (JSSC), had gathered outside the Assembly demanding government intervention.

“We Want Justice,” protesters could be heard shouting as police moved in to clear the area.

Some students insisted that they had no intention of entering the Assembly premises and simply wanted the government to listen to their demands. We don’t want to go inside. We want our rights. We have come here to demand what is rightfully ours,” one student said during the protest. However, the situation became tense as some protesters refused to move. Police personnel began pushing students away from the area and, according to several protesters and eyewitness accounts, some students were hit with batons.

One female student who was being removed from the protest reportedly became unconscious and was taken away in an ambulance.

Another student described how she injured her leg while trying to escape after police allegedly ordered protesters to move quickly.

I was surrounded by police personnel. They told us to run and get out. I was with three other people, but I don’t know where they are now, she said.

She claimed that she fell and twisted her leg while trying to leave the area. According to her, even after she was injured, police personnel continued asking protesters to move quickly.

Another protester alleged that he saw a student fall on the ground and claimed that several police personnel hit him while he was down.

The police, however, maintained that they were attempting to control a large crowd and disperse protesters after the situation became difficult to manage.

This further escalated the situation, with police using force to disperse the remaining protesters.https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/jharkhand/jharkhand-protest-live-updates-august-11-2026/article71330994.ece

Unidentified Elements, So Called Students

The protest leaders, however, argued that the majority of the demonstration had remained peaceful and blamed unidentified elements for creating chaos.

Vinay Mehta, one of the faces associated with the student movement, acknowledged that some “elements” may have entered the crowd and disrupted the protest. He said that the protesters had initially planned to remain peaceful and sit at the designated location, but the situation changed as the crowd grew.

The protest had been continuing for around 17 days, according to the students, with some protesters also claiming that several days had been spent on hunger strike. Mahendra Nath Mahto, who said he had been on hunger strike for nine days, alleged that police personnel pushed him and used batons against him while he was protesting.

“Government does not run through lathis, bullets or guns. A government runs by keeping the people satisfied,” he said. The students’ demands are largely connected to alleged irregularities in competitive examinations conducted in Jharkhand.

Protesters demanded reforms in JPSC and JSSC and called for an investigation into alleged examination irregularities, including claims surrounding the Combined Graduate Level (CGL) examination.

Some protesters demanded a CBI investigation, while others also called for an ED investigation into alleged corruption and irregularities.

One protester claimed that the examination system had been compromised and alleged that evidence had emerged regarding irregularities in recruitment examinations. These are allegations made by the protesters and would require verification through official investigations and court proceedings. The students also questioned the functioning of the commissions and demanded accountability from officials associated with the recruitment process.

One protester argued that the issue was not simply about jobs but about the credibility of the entire recruitment system.

“JSSC and JPSC need full reforms,” another student said, adding that candidates wanted transparency and accountability in the examination process.

Some protesters raised slogans against Chief Minister Hemant Soren and demanded that the government personally intervene in the matter. One student leader declared that the next day should not be about ministers holding meetings inside the Assembly but about the government meeting with students.

While one group wanted to enter the Assembly premises and continue their protest inside, another group insisted that they should remain outside and conduct the demonstration peacefully.https://unbiasedpollkhol.com/

Akhil Bharatiya Vidyarthi Parishad (ABVP) Role

Members associated with the Akhil Bharatiya Vidyarthi Parishad (ABVP) were also present at the protest, while representatives associated with other political groups were reportedly seen among the crowd.

This raised another question: had the student movement been joined or influenced by political organisations?

Some student leaders acknowledged that political and other outside elements may have entered the gathering. They said that identifying who was responsible for stone-pelting and other incidents would now be a matter for investigation. But another side of the story was presented by people associated with the protest, who argued that the police had shown considerable restraint given the size of the crowd.

One observer said that thousands of people were present and that the police had spent several hours trying to manage the gathering. According to this view, the situation became increasingly difficult once the crowd moved from a controlled protest location onto the streets.

For the students, however, the central issue remains their demand for transparency in recruitment examinations and action against alleged irregularities. The students say they have been waiting for answers for days. They want the government to address their concerns, investigate the allegations and reform the recruitment system.

At the same time, the events outside the Assembly have raised serious questions about crowd management, the use of force and the presence of non-student elements in the protest.

The protest began peacefully, but by evening the Assembly premises had largely been cleared.

Students were dispersed, some were reportedly detained, several claimed injuries, and allegations of lathi-charge were made. On the other side, allegations of stone-pelting and the throwing of chairs at police have also emerged.

As one protester put it, “We want justice.”

What happens next will depend not only on the government’s response but also on whether the student movement can maintain its peaceful character while continuing to press for its demands. The allegations surrounding the recruitment examinations, the conduct of the police, the use of force and the alleged involvement of outside elements will ultimately need to be established through proper investigation and evidence.

For now, one thing is clear: the students are not ready to give up.

“We will not leave this fight, no matter what happens,” one protester said.

    0 0 votes
    Article Rating
    Subscribe
    Notify of
    guest
    0 Comments
    Oldest
    Newest Most Voted
    0
    Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
    ()
    x